The Ventilator

Incorporating The Ranger's Blog

Trees

This cannot be natural

Matthew Chatfield
Latest posts by Matthew Chatfield (see all)

The Ranger’s fond of reading Ben Goldacre’s Guardian column ‘Bad Science‘. It features regular and entertaining debunking of scientific inaccuracy, health scares, pseudoscience and quackery.

Unicorn and rainbow

Ben normally aims his precision-targeted criticism at the biggest targets, so he probably won’t draw your attention to the following example of one poor deluded woman fighting for her rights:

She narrates the video:

I’m just wondering what the heck is in our water supply, what the heck is in our oxygen supply…. of metallic oxide salts that create a rainbow effect in a sprinkler. This cannot be natural… we all know it wasn’t something that happened twenty years ago…

It’s a salutary lesson to us all – just listen to the poor old dear rambling on, and you can hear phrases of fear and incomprehension that can typically be expressed in what passes for popular scientific debate across a range of topics. Issues such as the MMR vaccine, telecommunications masts, WiFi fear, and many more are often rounded up under the same paranoic tin-foil-lined umbrella, and debated with as much integrity. If ever there is any merit in these concerns, it is often lost in the cacophony of unfounded and ill-informed claims. It’s a shame that in such a technologically advanced society we seem to have created a situation where it’s acceptable or even attractive to remain ignorant of such basic, wholesome and interesting science as how a rainbow is made.

Matthew Chatfield

Uncooperative crusty. Unofficial Isle of Wight cultural ambassador. Conservation, countryside and the environment, with extra stuff about spiders.

3 thoughts on “This cannot be natural

  • I think that our government’s thrist for resources is prodominatly the reason why rainbows are huddled fearfully on the ground instead of flying free around the sun and the moon. (spelling suggestions above from the captions in the film)

    I remember getting yelled at (gently) for wasting water and spraying everything and everyone in sight when I was a kid (more than twenty years ago) for spraying the hose just so that I could see the rainbow I made.

    I am laughing instead of crying at this video because I am shocked that someone is so misinformed. Are you sure it isn’t a hoax? Still, I enjoyed it immensely. And now I am going to donate to some educational charity. As quickly as possible.

    Reply
  • Prodominatly? Is that a scientific term?

    Reply
  • ghostmoth

    You mean I won’t find a pot of gold at the rainbow’s end?!? Next you’ll be telling me that Father Christmas doesn’t exist!

    The Ranger responds: no, not gold, those evil metallic oxide salts… or something.

    Reply

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.