The Ranger's Blog

Post details: Rural riddler 3

Rural riddler 3

Well done for getting No. 2 so quickly - here's the next Find the Fault.

This is a bit harder, so let's see if anyone can get a bonus point too. Once more the relevant details are clear to see... good luck!

[More:]

The answer is in the comments. Scroll down to see it. Meanwhile, here's a great video of some horse-drawn ploughs to give you a clue!

11 comments so far, see them and add yours here!

Posted on 6th September 2008 at 4 50 pm
by The Virtual Ranger
382 views

Categories: Find the Fault

Permalink

Comments:

Comment from: Richard · http://honesthypocrite.blogspot.com/

It looks like the leaves are off of the tress in the background, so I think that he is plowing and getting ready to plant in the Fall which is the wrong season. He should plant in the Spring.

Permalink 06/09/08 @ 18:22

Comment from: pascal · http://monseilh.blogspot.com

It looks like the horses are missing the part of the coupling which goes in front of their breast.
Without that the flanges will just slide on their back as they try to pull the cart.

Permalink 06/09/08 @ 19:12

Comment from: Richard Comont

I'd agree - he seems to be ploughing grassland in the autumn, rather than the spring, and the horses are missing their pulling collars

Permalink 06/09/08 @ 23:09

Comment from: jonathan L · http://web.njit.edu/~jcl7

say he is plowing a "field"
it looks like he's on the border between dirt and crops. you don't plow crops!
Also, one typically uses oxen or mules for plowing and other low-speed high force jobs.

Permalink 07/09/08 @ 03:16

Comment from: The Wildlife Gardener [Admin]

You would need only one horse for a plough that size?? Also the big collars that draught horses wear to pull things are missing.

Permalink 07/09/08 @ 13:41

Comment from: Simon

Well the obvious is the missing collars as most people have pointed out, but I would also suggest that pulling a plough with a couple of bits of string might prove problematic.

Permalink 08/09/08 @ 09:16

Comment from: The Wildlife Gardener [Admin]

The farmer has only one leg?

Permalink 08/09/08 @ 14:12

Comment from: David Larkin · http://www.brighton-hove.gov.uk/index.cfm?request=c1190114

It is the lack of collars on the horses.
Most farmers round here do plough in the autumn now and sow winter wheat, although when these cards were published they would have ploughed in the spring as soon as the ground was dry enough (before the trees came into leaf) and planted sping wheat. Also a pair of shire horses was quite normal on heavy soils, although around here it was more typically oxen.

Permalink 10/09/08 @ 10:22

Comment from: The Virtual Ranger [Admin] · http://naturenet.net

Well done all - a lot of correct answers. Pascal gets the point for being the first to notice the official answer:

The horses have no breast collars.

Not many of us will ever have seen horses ploughing, so it's quite a tricky one. But in 1930 few adults living anywhere near a farm would not have seen a horse-drawn plough at some point, even if they were well on the decline by then. Check out the original post where I've put an interesting video of horses ploughing.

Dave Larkin as ever addresses most of the other points - yes, a pair of horses is normal, as was early spring ploughing at that time - almost unknown today. It's probably also true that the trees came into leaf later in the spring in those days, too. Today even those few who plough in the spring would rarely do so in front of bare trees.

As for ploughing up crops - I'm afraid I don't agree, Jonathan, I think it's pretty normal to plough up a field with some kind of vegetation on it, be it stubble or weeds or whatever. If it didn't have growth on it it might not need ploughing!

Only one bonus point this time, for good observation to Simon - I thought the reins were pretty thin too. I was tempted by the unipod farmer... but not that tempted. Try harder, Ms. Gardener.

Look out for number four coming very soon!

Permalink 10/09/08 @ 19:54

Comment from: David Larkin · http://www.brighton-hove.gov.uk/index.cfm?request=c1190114

Can't agree about the rein's being too thin (although I think you mean the traces) have a look at
http://www.cwmdu.com/HORSE%20PLOUGHING%20(2).JPG
but then I have worked with heavy horses doing a coppice restoration!

Permalink 11/09/08 @ 09:45

Comment from: The Wildlife Gardener [Admin]

Aah - love those heavy horses in the video!

Permalink 11/09/08 @ 12:34

The thoughts and writings of The Virtual Ranger, since 1995 the host and mascot of Naturenet, the UK's most popular independent environmental website; along with interjections from his real-life alter ego, Matthew Chatfield, and others. Featuring not only Naturenet and countryside related stuff, but, as on Naturenet, plenty of other material - more or less at random - that takes The Ranger's fancy. But you can be confident that soon enough he'll be rather sarcastic.

Mon	Tue	Wed	Thu	Fri	Sat	Sun
<< <
					1	2
3	4	5	6	7	8	9
10	11	12	13	14	15	16
17	18	19	20	21	22	23
24	25	26	27	28	29	30

Post details: Rural riddler 3

Rural riddler 3

Comments: